Envelopes lying on the floor under a mail slot, one of them blue

How to Get More Leads From Your Website: Forms, Quizzes, Chat and Calls

A website can get steady traffic and still bring in almost no leads. Usually it's not one button but a chain of small things: ads send people to the wrong page, the offer isn't clear from the first screen, the form asks for too much, and the lead that does come in sits in an inbox for a week.

Let's look at what website conversion is and how to measure it, why leads are scarce, which contact options to choose, how to set up a contact form and how to avoid losing leads after they're submitted.

What website conversion is and how to measure it

Conversion rate is the share of visitors who complete a target action. For a service business, that's a form submission, a call or a message; for an online store, it's an order. The formula is simple: divide the number of conversions by the number of sessions for the same period and multiply by 100%.

The easiest place to measure it is Google Analytics, using key events. Each contact method needs its own event:

The average conversion rate for the whole website tells you little. Break it down by traffic source, device and landing page: that's how you see, for example, that mobile ads bring people who never get to the form, while desktop search converts well.

Why your website gets few leads: from cause to fix

Before changing buttons, go through the possible causes in order. Each one only matters if the previous one has been ruled out.

  1. The wrong traffic. Ads target overly broad keywords; SEO brings people looking for information rather than ready to buy. Check: the search terms report and engagement rate by channel.
  2. An unclear offer. The first screen doesn't make clear what you do, for whom, roughly what it costs and what happens after someone reaches out. People leave to look somewhere clearer.
  3. No trust. No portfolio, company details, address, reviews or terms. On an unfamiliar website, people won't leave their phone number until they're sure the company is real.
  4. An awkward form. Lots of required fields, a CAPTCHA, unexplained errors, a form that breaks in one of the browsers.
  5. A slow website. The page takes several seconds to load, and the form or chat loads last.
  6. A weak mobile version. The call button is hidden, fields are hard to fill in, a pop-up covers the screen with no close button.

The first three causes are about marketing and content; the last three are about interface and technology. If the problem is the traffic or the offer, no form will bring back leads that were never there.

Contact options: form, quiz, messaging apps, phone, chat

People differ in how ready they are to reach out. One finds it easier to send a message, another prefers to call, a third wants to estimate the cost first without talking to anyone. That's why a website usually needs two or three contact options, not one and not seven.

OptionWhen it fitsRisks
Contact formThe universal choice, especially for B2B and detailed requestsA long form scares people off; leads get lost without notifications
QuizServices that need a quote: renovation, furniture, windows, constructionLots of cold contacts; annoying if there are too many questions
Messaging app buttonsB2C and small businesses that can reply quicklyConversations happen outside the CRM; conversion is hard to track
Phone and callbackUrgent services and complex products that need a conversationMissed calls after hours; "we'll call you back in a minute" promises
Live chatWebsites with pre-purchase questions, online storesA chat with no one answering is worse than no chat
CalculatorWhen the price can be calculated from a few parametersA wrong estimate undermines trust; prices need maintaining

Website quizzes

A quiz is a series of multiple-choice questions, at the end of which a person leaves their contact details to get a quote or a set of options. It lowers the barrier: answering questions is easier than writing a request from scratch. The downside is that some people leave contacts out of curiosity, so sales reps have to do more filtering. Keep the quiz short, and deliver what you promised at the end: a quote, a price range or a specific offer.

Messaging app buttons and live chat

Messaging buttons are convenient because people write from an app they already use and don't lose the conversation. But messages should land in a shared channel or the CRM, not on one sales rep's personal phone. The same goes for live chat: it works when someone is on the other end. After hours, it's more honest to show a "we'll reply in the morning" form than to leave a permanent "typing..." indicator.

Phone calls and callbacks

The phone number in the header should be tappable on mobile. A callback option helps when people find it awkward to call themselves, but only promise what you actually deliver. A widget that promises a call back in thirty seconds and never calls does more harm than having no widget at all.

Contact form design: making it easy to use

The form is the most common contact method and the most common place where leads get lost. A few rules that work almost every time:

Consent and personal data

If a form collects a name, phone number or email, that's personal data, and data protection law such as GDPR applies. The website needs a published privacy policy, and the form should link to it. If you rely on consent, for example to add people to a mailing list, the checkbox is never pre-ticked for the user. It's best to have a lawyer review the consent wording and the policy: requirements change, and a template from the internet may not fit your case.

What to show after submission

The confirmation screen is part of the form, not a formality. People need to know the request went through and what happens next. A good thank-you screen says who will get in touch and when, what hours the team works, and what the person can do right now: browse the portfolio, or send a message if the question is urgent. A separate page or event after a successful submission also makes a reliable conversion event for Google Analytics.

The confirmation screen is part of the form, not a formality.

Where to place calls to action

You don't need a "Get in touch" button on every screen. A call to action belongs where the person has enough information to make a decision.

Button text works better when it describes the outcome rather than the action: "Get a quote" is clearer than "Submit." Pop-ups on entry usually hurt more than they help, especially on mobile.

How not to lose leads after submission

Getting more leads from your website is half the job. The other half is making sure every one of them gets handled. This is where website leads that marketing has already paid for are most often lost.

As a web development agency, we build this in from the start: a lead should go where someone actually works on it, not just into an inbox. You can see examples in our work.

A/B tests: when they make sense with low traffic

An A/B test compares two versions of a page across different parts of the audience. For a reliable result, each version needs enough conversions, not just visits. If the website gets a few leads a week, a button color test will run for months and still show random noise.

With low traffic, a different approach is more useful:

Full-scale A/B tests start paying off when you have enough traffic and conversions to get a result within a few weeks.

Checklist: how to increase website conversions

FAQ

What is a good website conversion rate?

There's no single benchmark: it depends on your niche, the price of the product, the traffic source and what you count as a conversion. It's more useful to compare the website with itself over time and across channels, and to look not only at leads but at the share that turns into deals.

Which is better: a contact form or a quiz?

A quiz works well for services where people need a quote but find it hard to describe what they want. A form is more versatile and brings in more considered inquiries. They're often combined: a quiz for estimating the price and a short form for those who already know what they want.

Do I need a consent checkbox on my contact form?

If the form collects a name, phone number or email, that's personal data, and data protection law such as GDPR applies. You need a published privacy policy linked from the form, and if you rely on consent, for example to send marketing emails, the checkbox must never be pre-ticked. It's best to have a lawyer review the exact wording.

How many fields should a form have?

For a first contact, a name and one way to get in touch are enough. Everything else can be clarified in conversation or made optional. If you really can't process a request without more details, split the form into steps.

How quickly should you respond to a website lead?

As fast as possible during business hours: while people wait for a reply, they contact other companies. Agree on a response standard within the team and state honestly on the website when you reply to requests left in the evening and on weekends.

Let’s discuss your project
Related reading